Indian Roadmaster Dark Horse Review
"A genuinely compelling Harley alternative that rewards experienced, patient riders."
Key Specs
Used Buyer Review
The Roadmaster Dark Horse is Indian's bruiser done in murdered-out black, and honestly it's one of the better used buys in the touring segment right now. The Thunder Stroke 116 is a gem — smooth, torquey, and genuinely reliable if the previous owner wasn't an idiot about servicing. Check the oil change history religiously. These motors will run forever with proper maintenance but get neglected and you're looking at expensive fixes fast. The infotainment system on later models is genuinely excellent, not just decent-for-a-motorcycle excellent. Ride quality beats comparable Harleys straight up, no argument. Where it gets complicated is weight management in slow-speed parking lot stuff — this thing is heavy and it will punish you if you're not ready for it. Aftermarket support is growing but still nowhere near Harley levels, so budget accordingly. Watch for fairing stress cracks around the lower mounts on higher-mileage examples, and check that the air ride suspension (if equipped) cycles properly. Dealers aren't everywhere, which matters when you're broken down in Montana.
Pros
Cons
New riders or those near no Indian dealers
Similar Touring Reviews
"The used bike market's most sensible luxury touring purchase, full stop."
Two-up touring riders covering serious interstate miles $8,000-$18,000
"The benchmark sports tourer that absolutely nothing has made obsolete."
Experienced riders wanting fast, fuss-free long-distance touring $5,000-$11,000
"The thinking rider's sport-tourer that embarrasses more expensive alternatives."
Commuters who weekend tour at pace $8,500-$12,000
"The ultimate touring machine if you respect its weight and wallet."
Long-distance tourers who ride seriously, often $12,000-$22,000