⚡ Quick Answer: Best Year — 2022 or 2023 Indian Challenger These model years hit the sweet spot of a fully matured platform. Indian had ironed out first-generation teething issues, the PowerPlus 108 engine was proven reliable, and features like semi-active suspension (on Dark Horse variants) and refined electronics made them the most complete package without the premium cost of the very latest models. If budget allows, 2023 is our top pick overall.